Stovies

Name: Stovies
Total time: 55 min
Yield: Serves 4
Cuisine: Scotland, the Lowlands and the Central Belt
Ingredients: 1 tbsp sunflower oil; a knob butter; 1 kg white potatoes, thinly sliced; 1 large onion, thinly sliced; 300 g cooked beef, diced; to taste salt and black pepper; to taste freshly grated nutmeg; 4 tbsp parsley or chives, finely chopped; 450 ml beef stock

Glasgow tenement kitchens

Stovies: a deep bowl of soft broken-down potato and shredded lamb in a thick brown gravy, flecked with pale strands of onion.

Illustration

Time: 55 minutes

Researched: 10 sources cited

Leftover roast meat, potato and onion, layered and cooked low and slow in the fat and gravy left over from a Sunday joint until the potatoes break down and thicken the whole dish. Every household's version is different, and none is more correct than another.

by Glasgow tenement kitchens

A single end or a room and kitchen, a coal range kept lit from morning to night as the only source of heat, hot water and cooking, was the ordinary Glasgow working household for most of a century, and the food habits that grew out of it, stretching a Sunday joint into a Monday stovies, building a filling macaroni pie from little more than pasta, cheese sauce and pastry, were survival cooking made into permanent local taste rather than poverty imitating better food. Scots for a packed lunch, "a piece," entered popular memory permanently through Adam McNaughtan's 1960s song "The Jeely Piece Song," in which a mother in a new tower block throws a jam sandwich down to her child in the street below: gentle satire on the same slum clearance programme that was, at the time, meant to be improving exactly this kind of life. Glasgow does carry a genuine, well documented excess mortality rate, higher than Liverpool or Manchester even after full statistical adjustment for deprivation, the so called Glasgow effect. What the research does not support is pinning that excess on diet alone: the fullest academic synthesis, a joint 2016 study from the Glasgow Centre for Population Health, NHS Health Scotland, the University of the West of Scotland and UCL, points instead to deindustrialisation, political and policy vulnerability, and the fact that roughly half of the excess deaths under 65 relate directly to alcohol and drugs. A more recent academic reading argues the whole phenomenon is better called a political effect than a Glasgow one. The finding stands as real and the diet based explanation for it as unproven.

Read the history

As tradition built it

Serves 4. 15 minutes' preparation, 30 to 40 minutes' cooking.

Ingredients

1 tbsp sunflower oil
a knob butter
1 kg white potatoes, thinly sliced
1 large onion, thinly sliced
300 g cooked beef, diced
to taste salt and black pepper
to taste freshly grated nutmeg
4 tbsp parsley or chives, finely chopped
450 ml beef stock

Method

Heat the oil and butter in a large pan.
Layer in the potatoes, onion and beef, seasoning and sprinkling with nutmeg and herbs as you go.
Pour over the stock, cover, and cook 30 to 40 minutes, shaking the pan now and then, until the potatoes at the bottom are soft and those at the top just tender.
Scatter with more herbs and black pepper and serve.

Notes

Every credible source agrees the dish varies enormously from household to household, built as it always was from whatever a Sunday joint left behind, and no single recipe is more correct than another.

The recipe is Make it Scotch's, Quality Meat Scotland's. Sue Lawrence's in Scots Cooking, read only as transcribed on Mumsnet, has no meat: onions fried golden in 2 heaped tablespoons of dripping, potatoes turned in the fat, 2 tablespoons of meat jelly, about 40 minutes covered on a low heat, the pan shaken and never stirred. Catherine Brown's Broths to Bannocks softens the onion in dripping and gravy without browning and slices the potatoes in varying thicknesses. None uses lamb.

What a modern chef changes

The lamb held separately at a precise temperature, and two potato textures instead of one

Rungs 1 and 5

Method

Cook the lamb separately and precisely, sous vide at 56°C for the leg or shoulder trim used, so it stays properly pink and tender rather than cooking further in the pot, then fold it through only at the very end.
Build the base not from loose stock but from a properly reduced lamb jus, made from the same joint's bones.
Finish the potatoes' texture deliberately: some cooked whole and fondant in the jus, some blitzed in a high power blender to a smooth purée and stirred back through, giving the dish a controlled range of potato textures rather than the single, softened mass the traditional slow simmer produces by accident.

Open in the atlas: cook mode, scaling and tick off lists