Not Just Stew · The atlas · A working atlas of the world's cooking

The Caribbean · Volume 10, Pimento Smoke, the Maroon Fire and the Ital Table

Mannish water

Jamaica

Mannish water, goat head soup with dumplings: a deep bowl of clear pale broth holding pieces of goat meat, small dense flour dumplings, chunks of yam and green banana.

An illustration of the dish, not a photograph of it cooked.

Time
1 hour 30
Researched
No outside sources linked
Reviewed
Not yet reviewed from inside the tradition
Cooked
Not yet cooked and reported

As tradition built it

Mannish water

Serves 6 to 8 . About 1 hour 30 minutes

Ingredients

An outline, not yet a recipe: the tradition's method with its ingredients named but not weighed. Quantities are being added from sources inside the tradition, lead dishes first.

Method

  1. Make a soup from goat head and offal with yam, potato, green banana and dumplings.

Notes

Traditionally served to the groom on his wedding night and widely believed an aphrodisiac, and also served at wakes and large gatherings.

A claim that it has been part of Maroon celebration culture for over three hundred years is unverified and this chapter holds it cautiously rather than asserting it.

What a modern chef changes

A two-stage stock, clarified

Method

  1. Build the stock in two separate stages, offal and bones roasted first for real depth before the long simmer.
  2. Clarify through a chinois into a genuinely clear broth rather than the cloudy result a single long boil gives.
  3. Poach the dumplings separately and add them only at the point of serving, so they hold their shape rather than dissolving into the pot over the soup's long cook.
Open in the atlas: cook mode, scaling and tick off lists