Not Just Stew · The atlas · A working atlas of the world's cooking

North Africa · Volume 15, Harissa and the Ottoman Line

Chorba beida

Algiers

Chorba beida: A pale ivory broth, clear rather than cloudy, with walnut sized meatballs, whole chickpeas and small grains of bird's tongue pasta suspended through it. Not a trace of red anywhere. Chopped coriander and parsley over the surface and a lemon wedge on the rim of the bowl.

An illustration of the dish, not a photograph of it cooked.

Time
45 minutes
Researched
Researched from 123 sources in the brief, none yet linked in the text
Reviewed
Not yet reviewed from inside the tradition
Cooked
Not yet cooked and reported

Algerian soup runs on a binary that organises the entire repertoire: chorba beida, white, against chorba hamra, red. It is white because tomato has been deliberately excluded, in a country whose interior cooks almost nothing without it. That exclusion is the Ottoman city speaking. If you cook this and it tastes thin, the fault is almost never the missing chilli. It is the missing smen and the missing broth.

As tradition built it

Serves 4. About 45 minutes.

Ingredients

Method

  1. Sweat the onion in the oil until soft and pale. Do not colour it. Browning would put a red note into a white soup.
  2. Add the chickpeas and celery, crumble in the stock cube, add the water, and simmer 30 minutes.
  3. Meanwhile bind the minced meat with minced parsley, the flour, salt and pepper, and roll into walnut-sized balls. Brown them lightly, or drop them straight into the broth.
  4. Once boiling, rain in the pasta and cook 10 minutes more.
  5. Remove the celery, adjust the seasoning, and finish with coriander and lemon juice.

Notes

After a published Algerian source.

What a modern chef changes

A real broth, smen instead of the cube, and the pasta timed to the table

Rungs 6, 3 and 1

Method

  1. Replace the stock cube, because it is doing all the work and doing it badly. In a soup with no tomato, no chilli and no browning, the broth is the entire dish. Carcass and wings in cold water, brought slowly to 90°C and held three hours without ever boiling, skimmed, strained, reduced by a third. A boiled stock emulsifies its fat and goes cloudy, which is exactly wrong for a soup whose name is its colour. This change is worth more than all the others combined.
  2. Finish with smen, off the heat. A teaspoon of aged clarified butter at the end supplies the funk this repertoire is built on and that oil cannot. Without it the same soup tastes like an under-seasoned minestrone with the tomato left out.
  3. Cook the pasta to the table, and put the lemon on it too. Lsan el teer keeps swelling in hot broth, so a chorba that has stood twenty minutes is porridge: add it ten minutes before people sit down. The lemon wedge on the side is Rung 6, and the traditional service anyway.
Open in the atlas: cook mode, scaling and tick off lists